Note 12 Compensation, participations and loans of members of governing bodies
The section below is in line with articles 663bbis and 663c para. 3 of the Swiss Code of Obligations, which require disclosure of the elements of compensation paid to Swiss Re’s Board of Directors and Group Executive Committee (Group EC), as well as their shareholdings and loans.
Compensation for acting members of governing bodies
Article 663bbis of the Swiss Code of Obligations requires disclosure of total compensation paid to members of the Board of Directors and the Group EC. Compensation to members of the Board of Directors and the highest paid members of the Group EC are shown by individual. For a description of the elements of this compensation, see chapter Compensation.
Compensation of the Group EC
Aggregate compensation for members of the Group EC was:
Download |
|
9 members |
16 members5 | ||||||||||
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 | ||||||||||
| ||||||||||||
Base salary and allowances1 |
10 687 |
12 985 | ||||||||||
Funding of pension benefits |
1 397 |
1 656 | ||||||||||
Total fixed compensation |
12 084 |
14 641 | ||||||||||
Cash Annual Performance Incentive2 |
9 573 |
12 394 | ||||||||||
Value Alignment Incentive (VAI) |
5 378 |
8 359 | ||||||||||
Long-term incentives (LPP)3 |
6 250 |
12 400 | ||||||||||
Total variable compensation |
21 201 |
33 153 | ||||||||||
Total fixed and variable compensation4 |
33 285 |
47 794 | ||||||||||
Compensation due to members leaving |
1 448 |
2 268 | ||||||||||
Total compensation |
34 733 |
50 062 |
The table above covers payments to 16 members in 2012, of whom seven were employed for the full year. This also takes into account changes in the composition of the Group EC, reflecting the Group’s new corporate structure and operating model. The 2011 payments cover nine members, of whom eight were employed for the full year.
The fair value of the Value Alignment Incentive (VAI) is based on the nominal amount of the grant. Subsequently, a disbursement factor, which can vary between 50% and 150%, is applied based on the economic results of the Group. The VAI disclosed in the table above assumes a disbursement factor of 100% at grant date. For a description of the VAI plan see chapter Compensation.
The Long Term Incentive plan (LTI) was replaced by a new plan, the Leadership Performance Plan (LPP) in 2012. The first grant was made in March 2012 under the new plan. The LPP grants made in 2012 and 2013 are expected to be settled in shares, and the requisite service as well as the maximum contractual term are three years. At grant, the award is split into two equal underlying components: a Restricted Share Unit (RSU) and a Performance Share Unit (PSU). The RSU component is measured against a RoE performance condition and will vest within a range of 0–100%. The PSU is based on relative total shareholder return, measured against a pre-defined basket of peers and will vest within a range of 0–200%. The fair values of both components are measured separately, based on stochastic models. For further information on the LPP award, see chapter Compensation.
For US GAAP and statutory reporting purposes, VAI and long-term incentive awards are accrued over the period during which they are earned. For the purpose of the disclosure required of this note, the value of awards granted are included as compensation in the year of performance, for the years 2012 and 2011 respectively.
Certain members of the Group EC and the Board of Directors participate in a defined contribution scheme and their pension funding compensation in the remuneration table above reflects the actual employer contributions. Where defined benefit arrangements exist, the funding is determined on an actuarial basis, which can vary substantially from year to year depending on age and years of service of the benefiting members.
Highest paid member of the Group EC
In 2012, Michel M. Liès, Group CEO, was the highest paid member of the Group EC. The compensation of the Group CEOs for the respective periods was:
Download |
Stefan Lippe, Group CEO from February 2009 until January 2012 |
|
| ||||
Michel M. Liès, Group CEO since February 2012 |
|
| ||||
CHF thousands |
2011 |
20122 | ||||
| ||||||
Base salary and allowances |
2 180 |
1 663 | ||||
Funding of pension benefits |
175 |
175 | ||||
Total fixed compensation |
2 355 |
1 838 | ||||
Cash Annual Performance Incentive |
3 000 |
1 450 | ||||
Value Alignment Incentive (VAI) |
0 |
1 450 | ||||
Long-term incentives (LPP)1 |
0 |
2 000 | ||||
Total variable compensation |
3 000 |
4 900 | ||||
Total compensation |
5 355 |
6 738 |
Compensation of the Board of Directors
Group fees for the members of the Board of Directors are delivered as 60% in cash and a mandatory 40% in Swiss Re shares with a four year vesting period.
In 2009 and 2010, the Chairman and Vice Chairman received half of their fees in the form of a three-year performance share plan and the balance in cash. The performance share plan is measured against total relative shareholder return (TSR). The 2009 and 2010 performance shares were granted at a reference price of CHF 36.00 and CHF 53.60, respectively. The final number of shares to be released after three years can vary between 0% and 150% depending on the relative total shareholder return against a peer group. The Group did not grant a performance share plan in 2011 and 2012. The 2009 plan was settled in 2012.
The share prices as of 14 April 2011 of CHF 54.05 and as of 24 April 2012 of CHF 57.15 were used for calculating the number of shares awarded to the members of the Board of Directors based on the amount of the fee received in shares for 2011 and 2012 grants, respectively.
Aggregate compensation for the members of the Board of Directors was:
Download |
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 |
Fees and allowances in cash |
7 047 |
7 429 |
Fees in blocked shares |
4 678 |
4 862 |
Total |
11 725 |
12 291 |
Individual compensation for the Chairman and the two Vice Chairmen of the Board of Directors was:
Download |
Walter B. Kielholz, Chairman |
|
|
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 |
Fees and allowances in cash |
2 892 |
3 092 |
Total cash |
2 892 |
3 092 |
Fees in blocked shares |
1 912 |
2 045 |
Total |
4 804 |
5 137 |
Download |
Mathis Cabiallavetta, Vice Chairman1 |
|
| ||
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 | ||
| ||||
Fees and allowances in cash |
1 434 |
1 533 | ||
Total cash |
1 434 |
1 533 | ||
Fees in blocked shares |
956 |
1 023 | ||
Total |
2 390 |
2 556 |
Download |
Renato Fassbind, Vice Chairman1,2 |
|
| ||||
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 | ||||
| ||||||
Fees and allowances in cash |
150 |
277 | ||||
Total cash |
150 |
277 | ||||
Fees in blocked shares |
100 |
184 | ||||
Total |
250 |
461 |
Individual compensation of the remaining members of the Board of Directors was:
Download |
2011 |
Fees and allowances in cash |
Fees in shares |
Total | ||
| |||||
Jakob Baer, Chairman of the Audit Committee |
480 |
320 |
800 | ||
Raymund Breu, Member |
225 |
150 |
375 | ||
Raymond K.F. Ch’ien, Member |
225 |
150 |
375 | ||
John R. Coomber, Chairman of the Finance and Risk Committee |
426 |
280 |
706 | ||
Renato Fassbind, Member1 |
150 |
100 |
250 | ||
Rajna Gibson Brandon, Member |
210 |
140 |
350 | ||
Malcolm D. Knight, Member |
165 |
110 |
275 | ||
Hans Ulrich Maerki, Member |
195 |
130 |
325 | ||
Carlos E. Represas, Member |
165 |
110 |
275 | ||
Jean-Pierre Roth, Member |
180 |
120 |
300 | ||
Robert A. Scott, Chairman of the Compensation Committee |
300 |
200 |
500 | ||
Total |
2 721 |
1 810 |
4 531 |
Download |
2012 |
Fees and allowances in cash |
Fees in shares |
Total | ||||||||
| |||||||||||
Jakob Baer, Chairman of the Audit Committee |
484 |
323 |
807 | ||||||||
Raymund Breu, Member |
216 |
144 |
360 | ||||||||
Raymond K.F. Ch’ien, Member |
216 |
144 |
360 | ||||||||
John R. Coomber, Chairman of the Finance and Risk Committee1 |
299 |
196 |
495 | ||||||||
Rajna Gibson Brandon, Member |
201 |
134 |
335 | ||||||||
C. Robert Henrikson, Chairman of the Compensation Committee2 |
183 |
123 |
306 | ||||||||
Malcolm D. Knight, Member |
199 |
133 |
332 | ||||||||
Hans Ulrich Maerki, Member |
197 |
131 |
328 | ||||||||
Carlos E. Represas, Member3 |
274 |
111 |
385 | ||||||||
Jean-Pierre Roth, Member |
171 |
113 |
284 | ||||||||
Robert A. Scott, Chairman of the Compensation Committee4 |
87 |
58 |
145 | ||||||||
Total |
2 527 |
1 610 |
4 137 |
Compensation of former members of governing bodies
In 2011, a total of CHF 175 thousand was paid to former members of the Group EC. This figure relates to one individual and covers company taxation commitments. In 2012, in the context of the outstanding mortgages and loans not at market rates for former members as well as of risk benefits, the equivalent of approximately CHF 60 thousand was provided to three former members of the Group EC as a benefit in kind. No other compensation was paid to former members of the Group EC in 2012.
Group EC and Board of Directors share ownership, options and related instruments
Share ownership
The disclosure below is in line with article 663c para. 3 of the Swiss Code of Obligations, which requires disclosure of share ownership, options and related instruments individually for each member of the Board of Directors and the Group EC, including shares, options and related instruments held by persons closely related to, and by companies controlled by members of the Board of Directors and the Group EC.
Number of shares held as of 31 December were:
Download |
Members of the Group EC |
2011 |
2012 | ||||||||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||
Stefan Lippe, former Group CEO1 |
201 733 |
| ||||||||||||||
Michel M. Liès, Group CEO2 |
|
129 562 | ||||||||||||||
David J. Blumer, former Group Chief Investment Officer3 |
81 000 |
| ||||||||||||||
Guido Fürer, Group Chief Investment Officer4 |
|
1 500 | ||||||||||||||
Agostino Galvagni, CEO Corporate Solutions |
27 546 |
69 371 | ||||||||||||||
Brian Gray, former Group Chief Underwriting Officer5 |
30 601 |
| ||||||||||||||
Jean-Jacques Henchoz, CEO Reinsurance EMEA |
|
12 287 | ||||||||||||||
Christian Mumenthaler, CEO Reinsurance |
20 000 |
50 000 | ||||||||||||||
Moses Ojeisekhoba, CEO Reinsurance Asia6 |
|
1 139 | ||||||||||||||
George Quinn, Group CFO |
34 337 |
57 987 | ||||||||||||||
Matthias Weber, Group Chief Underwriting Officer7 |
|
24 237 | ||||||||||||||
Thomas Wellauer, Group Chief Operating Officer |
16 714 |
16 714 | ||||||||||||||
Total |
411 931 |
362 797 |
Download |
Members of the Board of Directors |
2011 |
2012 | ||||||||||
| ||||||||||||
Walter B. Kielholz, Chairman |
185 000 |
290 230 | ||||||||||
Mathis Cabiallavetta, Vice Chairman, Chairman of the Investment Committee, Chairman of the Finance and Risk Committee1 |
19 652 |
54 546 | ||||||||||
Renato Fassbind, Vice Chairman2 |
1 846 |
5 073 | ||||||||||
Jakob Baer, Chairman of the Audit Committee |
34 922 |
40 568 | ||||||||||
Raymund Breu, Member |
31 789 |
34 310 | ||||||||||
Raymond K.F. Ch’ien, Member |
10 719 |
13 240 | ||||||||||
John R. Coomber, Chairman of the Finance and Risk Committee3 |
134 707 |
138 134 | ||||||||||
Rajna Gibson Brandon, Member |
22 024 |
24 368 | ||||||||||
C. Robert Henrikson, Chairman of the Compensation Committee4 |
|
2 144 | ||||||||||
Malcolm D. Knight, Member |
3 538 |
5 857 | ||||||||||
Hans Ulrich Maerki, Member |
21 621 |
23 915 | ||||||||||
Carlos E. Represas, Member |
5 538 |
7 479 | ||||||||||
Jean-Pierre Roth, Member |
3 350 |
5 341 | ||||||||||
Robert A. Scott, Chairman of the Compensation Committee5 |
24 096 |
| ||||||||||
Total |
498 802 |
645 205 |
Restricted shares
Swiss Re grants restricted shares on an ad hoc basis that are subject to a vesting period with a risk of forfeiture during the vesting period.
The following unvested restricted shares were held by members of the Group EC as of 31 December:
Download |
Members of the Group EC |
2011 |
2012 | ||||
| ||||||
Weighted average share price in CHF as of grant date |
16.74 |
53.10 | ||||
David J. Blumer, former Group Chief Investment Officer1 |
149 342 |
| ||||
Moses Ojeisekhoba, CEO Reinsurance Asia2 |
|
13 093 | ||||
Total |
149 342 |
13 093 |
The restricted shares granted to Moses Ojeisekhoba, CEO Reinsurance Asia, have a step vesting period until 2014. For the years ended 31 December 2011 and 2012, the members of the Board of Directors did not hold any restricted shares.
Performance shares
In 2009 and 2010, the Chairman and the Vice Chairman received half their fees in the form of a performance share plan with a three-year vesting period. The Group did not grant any such plans in 2011 and 2012.
Number of performance units outstanding as of 31 December 2011 and 2012 were:
Download |
Members of the Board of Directors |
2011 |
2012 |
Walter B. Kielholz, Chairman |
125 415 |
55 971 |
Mathis Cabiallavetta, Vice Chairman |
69 653 |
27 986 |
Total |
195 068 |
83 957 |
Vested options
The following vested options were held by members of Group governing bodies as of 31 December:
Download |
|
Number of options | |||||||||||
Members of the Group EC |
2011 |
2012 | ||||||||||
| ||||||||||||
Weighted average strike price in CHF as of grant date |
99.90 |
82.32 | ||||||||||
Stefan Lippe, former Group CEO1 |
99 000 |
| ||||||||||
Michel M. Liès, Group CEO2 |
|
66 000 | ||||||||||
Guido Fürer, Group Chief Investment Officer3 |
|
7 500 | ||||||||||
Brian Gray, former Group Chief Underwriting Officer4 |
14 000 |
| ||||||||||
Christian Mumenthaler, CEO Reinsurance |
2 000 |
| ||||||||||
George Quinn, Group CFO |
31 000 |
26 000 | ||||||||||
Matthias Weber, Group Chief Underwriting Officer5 |
|
9 500 | ||||||||||
Total |
146 000 |
109 000 |
Download |
|
Number of options | |
Members of the Board of Directors |
2011 |
2012 |
Weighted average strike price in CHF as of grant date |
103.98 |
86.26 |
Walter B. Kielholz, Chairman |
110 000 |
40 000 |
John R. Coomber, Chairman of the Finance and Risk Committee |
250 000 |
210 000 |
Total |
360 000 |
250 000 |
The range of expiry years for vested options held by members of Group governing bodies as of 31 December 2011 and 2012 was 2012–2015 and 2013–2015, respectively.
Loans to members of governing bodies
The following loans were granted to members of governing bodies as of 31 December:
Download |
CHF thousands |
2011 |
2012 |
Total mortgages and loans to members of the Group EC |
3 753 |
3 710 |
Highest mortgages and loans to an individual member of the Group EC: |
|
|
Christian Mumenthaler, CEO Reinsurance |
2 167 |
2 143 |
Total mortgages and loans not at market conditions to former members of the Group EC |
9 610 |
4 300 |
Mortgages and loans to members of the Board of Directors |
|
|
Walter B. Kielholz, Chairman |
2 000 |
2 000 |
All credit is secured against real estate or pledged shares. The terms and conditions of loans and mortgages are the same as those available to all Swiss Re Group employees in the respective locations. In 2011 and 2012, all mortgages held by members of governing bodies were granted at Swiss terms and conditions. Fixed-rate mortgages have a maturity of five years and interest rates that correspond to the five-year Swiss franc swap rate plus a margin of 10 basis points. The variable-rate mortgages have no agreed maturity dates. The basic preferential interest rates equal the corresponding interest rates applied by the Zurich Cantonal Bank minus one percentage point. To the extent that fixed or adjustable interest rates are preferential, such values were factored into the compensation sums given to the governing body members.